Conversation

Ben Lubar (any pronouns)

bluesky's new pronoun field only shows up when you are actively replying to someone which makes it pretty much useless because why would you use a third person pronoun in that context

2
0
0

the existing pronoun labelers show up all the time and also don't have a limit of 20 characters

1
0
0

like this

I don't need to fill my pronouns field because it already says my pronouns three times in every context

I guess I could add a fourth time for one specific context but why even spend the effort to do that

2
0
0

@ben moderation label pronouns are only visible for those who are subscribed to the labeler which means they do not show up at all unless you figure out which the Current One Is

1
0
1

@ben i was following one before but it died at some point and i haven’t found what the hot new one is

1
0
1

@ben The answer is probably because "Someone vibe-coded it that way"

1
0
0

@zalasur they vibe coded it the day after the US election which is the funniest part

maybe they had some other feature planned for if the election had gone the other way

0
0
0

@charlotte the two I'm subscribed to are:
https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:vud7oo5sc7k256jjplfxlnhm
https://bsky.app/profile/did:plc:l3nbhdfelt5d26btksecetxu

but I find that display name pronouns work the best

certainly not "pronouns that can only be seen when you're in a context where third person pronouns aren't used"

0
0
1

@ben some languages like french conjugate the subject's gender with adjectives or verbs, so in *that* situation I'd understand.

1
0
0

@Ronflaix yeah but when are you most likely to be talking about someone

when you're replying directly to that person or when you're doing literally anything else?

0
0
0