Conversation

Charlotte lotteheartplural/Cinny cinny_heart_plural thetadelta ursaminor treblesand

Edited 1 month ago

everyone is like “don’t connect freezers to the internet” as if these are personal home freezers in your kitchen you can just walk to and if they are out of range you will probably be fine and not on the hook for health code violations or worse

4
1
2

@charlotte how would a freezer that's inaccessible to the people who work in the grocery store be useful

1
0
0

@ben consider: the person that maintains the freezer is not in the store

consider: employees aren’t incessantly checking freezer temps (something that the freezer already does and therefore can report to some computer system)

1
0
0

@charlotte there's a huge difference between a freezer that can report its temperature to some kind of meter that gets read remotely and a freezer with a remote code execution exploit that lets you turn it into an oven

I'm pretty sure the power company can read the power meter plugged into the back of my house from a car on the street but there's no way someone can unlock and unplug the meter from the street

1
0
0

@ben those are two separate issues actually. the “why is the freezer connected to the internet” turns a decent idea into The Problem while the real issue (almost nonexistent security controls) gets ignored because “you should have shrimply not connected it to the internet”

3
0
1

@charlotte if a store has (presumably) multiple refrigerators, then those refrigerators should not be directly connected to the internet but rather have their data aggregated and accessible via whatever device is aggregating the data

just like how anything in your house shouldn't be connected directly to the modem unless you're sure it's only got ports listening for things that it should be listening for

1
0
0

@ben my point is that the reason it was wasn’t because whoever installed it was “stupid” or “lazy” but because they need to care a lot more about the state of their numerous cooling equipment than you ever will

1
0
1

@charlotte I don't think the person who installed it had any ability to decide whether the refrigerators would receive commands from the internet

that's a design issue

0
0
0

@ben the new problem: tho device aggregating it has a hardcoded password (presumably these freezer web panels cover complete installations anyhow, but the issue is specifically not the “connecting it fo the internet part” but the “anyways we have zero security and neither does our client” bit)

0
0
1

@charlotte if freezers were never connected to satellites then technically there'd be absolutely no monitoring of refrigerated cars/trailers on trains and trucks

0
0
1

@charlotte personally i don't require folks to be so precise in their language when they're clearly complaining about corporate surveillance and weren't remotely thinking about normal temperature monitored devices

1
0
0

@matildalove i should also point out, again, these aren’t freezers that people just have in their home. businesses buy and run them. and open web interfaces isn’t something an end user is going to accidentally configure in their own home

1
0
0

@matildalove an instant “don’t connect [x thing] to the internet” response is about as useful as a “don’t click links” one to the latest phishing scam because at best it completely dismisses what the other person is trying to do offering zero alternatives

0
0
0

@charlotte there’s still a difference between an intranet and the Internet. such a device should have been only on the internal network and not THE PUBLIC INTERNET FOR EVERYONE TO JUST POKE AT

1
0
0

@eri while some affected freezers were directly accessible on the internet, it is unclear whether the ones in the recent european supermarket ones were. and while having an intranet will make exploitation harder, the affected chains were so massive that there are almost definitely stores with poor physical security and customer-accessible self-checkout machines that would have access to a corporate VPN tunnel.

1
0
0

@eri like unless there is a literal air gap if your network is large enough you just have to assume it’s like it’s the open web. it’s probably a good idea to treat it as such, especially considering that configuration errors happen (and with enough sites it will undoubtedly happen)

1
0
0

@eri (essentially there shouldn’t be A Problem if it is internet accessible. a bad idea? definitely, but not actively something that could cause financial or physical harm)

0
0
0

one thing that i have noticed is that the primary argument against doing that i have seen seems to involve insulting the other’s intelligence. don’t do that.

the actual problem is an industry wide problem is that IoT devices widely have garbage security. that is the problem, not the internet connected part.

4
0
1

@charlotte It’s not just garbage security, it’s also garbage privacy and garbage reliability. And I’m a bit concerned that solving all that will lead to IOT devices just being really spendy, which can then make them not a good idea in a lot of cases

1
0
0

@charlotte I've seen that way to much in other connects as well with regards to ICT/programming, often people refuse to understand any history or context and immediately start insulting people.

0
0
1

@aens context here isn’t consumer grade iot devices (which have more issues), but commercial equipment that is internet connected. like the freezers that got hacked

1
0
0

@charlotte Yeah, that’s fair, just pointing out that consumer IOT much does have the problems people were pointing out

0
0
0

@charlotte maybe it's actually because we live in a garbage society

0
0
0
@charlotte I wonder if smart devices would be safer with some sort of transmit-only architecture that would still allow monitoring, but you'd need to arrive in person to change settings (then again, if there was a physical failure you'd have to show up in person to fix it anyway).
0
0
0