Conversation

Replika Dorothy Haze (recently liberated from Eusan)

wait, wrt dual booting is there any reason i couldn't just have separate ESPs for each OS?
1
0
1
@aleteoryx EFI requires exactly one ESP, it may work it may not
2
0
1

@chjara @aleteoryx generally pc bioses do support it but it’s Not The Recommended Way To Do This and really only there to allow usb/dvd booting

1
0
3

@chjara @aleteoryx also unless you have a reason to remove one of these drives in the future, there is also no reason to not have windows and linux use the esp. they can share the same esp just fine unless you intentionally install grub/systemd-boot incorrectly

0
0
2
@chjara @aleteoryx Well I guess one could have something like grub/rEFind/… on the actual ESP which then just allows to load from secondary efi partitions (which could also be EFI bootloaders) dedicated to each OS.

Problem with that will likely be that turn-key non-configurable systems will likely want to destroy it at each update.
Like sounds good for Alpine/Arch/Gentoo/…; fine with BSDs; bad with Debian/Fedora/…; definitely not a good idea with Windows/MacOS.
0
0
1