Conversation
llm coding (vibe-coding), rant, long post
Show content
two days ago a vibe-coded application solved a problem i had and i used it with much disgust, and since then i've been thinking what exactly it is that makes me immediatly hit the alarm bells "vibe-coded" upon first booting it up.

TLDR: maybe friction ain't such a bad thing.

Programming UI's is annoying, I get it. UI toolkits make you hate everything about computers, they do everything as convoluted as possible, and they force you to use programming flows that are ill-fitted for many daily tasks.
As a result you often end up making tools for yourself for shovelling through the mountains of UI code. Need another widget? Might as well use the margin and padding calculation code that you used on your previous widget. This is a normal part of the programming cycle.
But also, if your client asks you to add another widget or invert the flow of a wizard you sigh, because now you got to refactor a big chunk of code you just wrote.
Hence why especially when working with UI's it's wise to have a strong pre-approved plan ahead for where the parts of the program will lay. You don't wanna change course half-way through.

LLM coding takes away all these frictions. It suddenly becomes very easy to just add another pane, another widget, and just improvise as you go. The model will just pick a random widget probably stolen from another application and inject it exactly where you say it will go, often reinventing the wheel as that widget had its own code for margin calculation instead of refactoring it to use the ones you used previously.


As a result these applications get many UI elements, often replicating tools build by teams of programmers over years, but with none of the consistence. It's like a company that only hires schoolars looking for internships, everyone does their own thing and nobody dares to say "no" to a feature. The resulting applications feel cluttered, inconsistent, and as if pressing on any unexpected part will break it as the LLM was never asked to guard against that and no human spend weeks tinkering with every button.

Sometimes less really is more, especially in programming. But try telling that to a manager...
0
1
1